What’s the problem with public education?

Reshmi Bisessar, Katrina Heschel, Nathalie Robertson, Doug Reid, and Allison Campbell-Rogers

Our synthesis map, “Imagine If… Education Focused on, Human Development?” explores the Ontario public education system from the primary grades of junior kindergarten, through to the completion of secondary school (currently, grade 12). We have been greatly inspired by the work of Sir Ken Robinson and his extraordinary vision of education to support the development of every person’s potential. For many years, Ontario’s public education system has been well-regarded and ranked highly in the Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) evaluation. However, these evaluations do not reflect the complete picture of Ontario’s education system. Ontario’s public education system is drifting towards a marketplace model. The COVID-19 pandemic uncovered shortcomings and pre-existing disruptions in the education system. Ontario was unable to meet the needs of all its students; not because of the Covid19-specific stress points of lockdown, distance, and integration of technology, but because it is a system, entrenched in inequity., A system built to support the pursuit of individual excellence will necessarily produce winners and losers. To better their child’s chances of “success,” families with means opt for elite private schools or enrol in costly, add-on services from emerging education innovations.

Meanwhile, changeovers of ruling political parties create oscillating ideologies that fail to support the needs of schools and education workers. The change we need to see in the education system is urgent because solving these complex problems and the challenges in the future we’ve yet to meet requires the full spectrum of human diversity and ability. We only reach our full potential when everyone is included. Our analysis indicates that the Ontario education system is currently vulnerable to a revolt initiated from the small-scale local level and the medium-scale district level. COVID-19 disruptions have created a groundswell of support for change and an experiential understanding that many educational orthodoxies are held in place due to habit, rather than policy mandate.

• Policymakers and governments can make changes directly to the system.
• Activists and community members can take a stand from outside the system and press for change.
• Principals standing in their unique position between students and policy can lead to change within their schools.

We have the opportunity now, amidst the tumult of these multi-headed crises, to overhaul our education systems and, by doing so, ensure that school becomes a pathway toward flourishing human development for everyone.